Stage 6 · Powers, Roots & Real Numbers

6.4  The Birth of Irrational and Real Numbers

Some roots never come out — and they force us to invent a bigger family of numbers.

For ages 12–14 · Intuition before notation
Knowledge point page

Point 1 of 5 in this lesson: 6.4.1 A root that won't come out: the mystery of √2

6.4.1 A root that won't come out: the mystery of √2

You already know how to undo a square. The side of a square of area 9 is 9 = 3; the side of area 16 is 4. These come out clean because 9 and 16 are perfect squares. But what about the diagonal of a unit square? Its length is 2 — the number whose square is exactly 2 — and 2 is not a perfect square. So what is this number?

Try to pin it down by squeezing. Since 12 = 1 and 22 = 4, the number √2 sits between 1 and 2. Test 1.4: 1.42 = 1.96, a touch too small. Test 1.5: 1.52 = 2.25, a touch too big. So √2 is between 1.4 and 1.5. Squeeze again with two decimals: 1.412 = 1.9881 and 1.422 = 2.0164, so it lies between 1.41 and 1.42. You can keep doing this all day — 1.414, 1.4142, 1.41421… — and the squeeze never closes onto a tick. The digits run on forever.

1 1 √2 Squeeze it between perfect squares: 1.4² = 1.96 … too small 1.41² = 1.9881 … too small √2 = 1.41421356… (never ends) 1.42² = 2.0164 … too big 1.5² = 2.25 … too big
The diagonal of a unit square is √2. Squeezing it between numbers whose squares straddle 2 traps it ever more tightly, but the trap never snaps shut on a clean decimal.

Compare this with an old friend, 13. Its decimal also runs forever: 0.3333…. But look — it repeats. The same block "3" comes back over and over, locked in a pattern, because the long division 1 ÷ 3 keeps giving the same remainder. A repeating decimal is just a fraction in disguise. The decimal of √2 is different in kind: 1.41421356237… shows no repeating block, ever. That is the clue that √2 is no fraction at all.

Watch out

"It goes on forever" is not what makes a number irrational. 13 = 0.333… goes on forever too, yet it is perfectly rational. The dividing line is whether the digits eventually repeat a block (rational) or never settle into any pattern (irrational).

Why √2 can't be a fraction — gently

Suppose √2 were a fraction pq in lowest terms. Squaring gives p² = 2q², so p² is even, which forces p itself to be even, say p = 2k. Then 4k² = 2q², so q² = 2k² — meaning q is even too. But p and q can't both be even if the fraction was in lowest terms! The assumption collapses. So no fraction squares to 2: √2 truly is a new kind of number.

🎮 Try itReveal the digits — does it repeat?

Add digits to each number and watch what happens. 1/3 and 1/4 settle down; √2 keeps surprising you.

Decimal places shown 4
eastmath.com · 6.4 The Birth of Irrational and Real Numbers · 6.4.1 A root that won't come out: the mystery of √2